Bethel hosts election debate in the Underground

College Democrats and College Republicans square off in an election debate Oct. 26.

Abby Petersen | News Editor

Four College Democrats and three College Republicans sipped from Dasani water bottles in the Bethel University Underground Wednesday night. They prepared to speak for the election debate hosted by Pi Sigma Alpha, the political science honor society group on campus.

The election debate, moderated by Student Body President Zoe Vermeer and Pi Sigma Alpha President Caitlin Navratil, was in the works since September. It came to life the night of Oct. 26. Within 10 minutes, the black plastic seats were filled in the lower level of the Underground. Students sat with their laptops open at tables on the second level. Before the debate began, moderators showed a video on civility, posted Oct. 17 on the Bethel Student Government Facebook page.

“The purpose of this evening is simply to inform and educate,” Vermeer said.

Moderators clarified that each side would be allowed two minutes to respond to each question and one minute for rebuttal if they chose. Audience members were allowed to submit questions during the debate for consideration.

College Republicans Senior Vice President John Ratliff answered the first question on major policy issues, saying that the national debt is left out of presidential debates and largely waved off by both candidates.

College Democrats President Daniel Gray cited issues such as climate change, abortion and social issues as the major policy issues for this election cycle.

_r4r4096
College Democrats President Daniel Gray speaks at the election debate Oct. 26. Gray was one of four College Democrats on stage during the event. “The goal for this was to provide a model … for Christian civility,” Gray said. | Photo by Nathan Klok

Representatives from both groups struggled to stay within time constraints as questions became more complex. Vermeer asked both groups how to fix distrust of police and public safety.

“We need more civilian leaders,” College Democrats representative Jessica Arend said.

College Republicans President Sam Krueger emphasized the importance of education, saying that the real issue is crime.

“We can’t legislate away prejudice,” Krueger said.

Moderators also asked both groups to respond to the refugee crisis, foreign policy, pay inequity and climate change. Both groups also shared their view on Christianity in American policy.

 

_r4r4119
College Republicans President Sam Krueger comments on issues such as the Affordable Care Act the night of Oct. 26. “Higher education is a privilege and not a right,” Krueger said of college tuition. | Photo by Nathan Klok

When the topic of the presidential nominees arose, College Democrats Vice President Berit Turnquist mentioned that Wednesday was Democratic presidential nominee Hillary Clinton’s 69th birthday. “She has proven herself to be an adept leader,” Turnquist said.

Krueger offered a differing view. “I think it’s really important to realize 55 years of experience doesn’t mean it’s okay to be corrupt,” he said. “You’d be hard-pressed to find a worse candidate for the first woman candidate of a major party.”

Neither group talked at length about Republican presidential nominee Donald Trump.

Representatives from both groups reacted positively to the debate after it was finished. Arend was pleasantly surprised by how many things both groups agreed on and College Republicans Executive Director Michael Cameron said that each group simply had different solutions to the same problems.

Rollie Olson, Vice President of Pi Sigma Alpha, thought the debate was a fruitful discussion.

“This was not about candidates, it was about the issues,” Olson said.

Freshman Ify Nwankwo wished there had been more “genuineness” among the two groups. “(I wanted to see someone) actually get worked up over something they actually believe,” she said.

“You have to vote your conscience,” Cameron said on stage. “A truly wasted vote is a vote for a candidate you don’t believe in.

College Democrats meet every other Wednesday at 7 p.m. in room 329 of the Academic Center. College Republicans meet every Thursday at 7 p.m. in Hagstrom Student Services Center room 241.

Additional reporting by Kylie Gregory, Nathanael Dallaire and Maddy Simpson.

How College Democrats and College Republicans line up on issues

Topic: Policing

R: Crime is the problem and education is the answer. Education reform in schools will help.

D: Education is helpful, but the real problem is implicit bias by police officers. Advocates for education for the police force.

Topic: Affordable Care Act

R: Not affordable. Should be repealed and replaced. “It can be crippling to families who once could afford to have insurance and now just can’t.” – Sam Krueger, President

D: Affordable Care Act should not be repealed.

Topic: Salary inequity between men and women

R: It’s illegal for companies to pay women less based on gender. Any inequity is a cultural problem, not a legislative one.

D: Barriers to women exist in the workplace. Government should increase options for maternity leave.

Topic: Student debt

R: If public higher education is tuition-free, the value of a degree goes down. Push for skill and trade schools instead. Does not believe it’s the government’s responsiblity to eliminate student debt. “Higher education is a privilege and it’s not a right.” – Sam Krueger, President

D: Eliminate tuition at public universities. Take steps toward forgiving student debt.

Topic: Abortion

R: Mostly against abortion except in cases of rape or incest.

D: Pretty much pro-choice. Believes there are less abortions under progressive leadership.

Topic: Hillary Clinton and third party candidates

R: Clinton is corrupt and not fit for the presidency. Republican party was once a third party.

D: Clinton is experienced and ready for office. Voting for a third party candidate is a wasted vote because one of the candidates from the major parties will win.

Topic: Syrian refugees

R: Neither increase or decrease the number of 10,000 refugees taken in. The government’s primary goal is to protect citizen’s rights.

D: Increase number of refugees taken in. The United Nations’ priority is to human rights, not just citizen rights. “This has become a human rights issue.” – Berit Turnquist, Vice President

Topic: Christianity in American policy

R:  Stick to Christian values, but the Founding Fathers might not agree. “We should not discriminate against people that have different ideals than us as long as they don’t harm one another.” – Sam Krueger, President

D:  The US is growing more and more diverse and should make space for that, including those who don’t identify with any religion at all. “The US should make room for the common ground that we share as US citizens instead of focusing in or turning a biased eye to Christian values specifically.” – Berit Turnquist, Vice President

Topic: Climate change

R: Advocates for nuclear energy. Developing nations shouldn’t be prevented from using fossil fuels.

D: Climate change is a big problem. Advocates for pursuing alternative energy methods such as wind or solar. Believes nuclear power has safety concerns.

Topic: US war in Aleppo, Syria

R: Support fight against ISIS without putting more American lives at stake. Refugees should be absorbed into surrounding countries.

D: America is justified in backing the rebel regime since Assad committed war crimes against Syrian people. “We need to approach this from a humanitarian standpoint.” – Daniel Gray, President